Latest comments

  • More on blue and pin...
    Nicolas Baumard More...
    Great post Ophelia! A very good topic for cognition and culture studies!

    As for the ... 3 hours ago
  • Brilliant!
    Lucy Fisher More...
    It\'s like when people say \"All you need is confidence\" or \"you\'ve got to have trus... 8 days ago
  • False Dichotomies
    Nicholas Smyth More...
    First: The idea of an unconscious mental realm as the source of our action and experien... 9 days ago
  • Fine print
    Olivier Morin More...
    Thank you very much, Young-Hoon Kim, for replying to Karen. I am glad to read from you ... 29 days ago
  • Wonderful Comments
    Young-Hoon Kim More...
    I really appreciate the comments by Karen Lofstrom. More of importance, I totally under... 29 days ago

Latest Blog Posts

Why pink? Color matters

Ophelia Deroy | 5/9/2010

Paul Rozin on what psychologists should study

Hugo Mercier | 28/7/2010

What if there had never been a Cognitive Revolution?

Nicolas Baumard | 22/7/2010

Paul the Octopus, relevance and the joy of superstition

Dan Sperber | 13/7/2010

Opacity tasting with Dan and Maurice

György Gergely | 11/7/2010

Homeopathy as witchcraft

Nicolas Baumard | 2/7/2010

The sacredness of God

Brian Malley | 27/6/2010

“Oy vey, have you got the wrong vampire!” A reply to Frans de Waal

Dan Sperber | 22/6/2010

Three Questions for Michael Tomasello

Emma Cohen | 20/6/2010

Why do acamedics oppose capitalism?

Nicolas Baumard | 14/6/2010

Communication, punishment and common pool resources

Hugo Mercier | 6/6/2010

Believing Maurice Bloch on doubting, doubting him on believing

Dan Sperber | 30/5/2010

Why do we make our tastes public?

Nicolas Baumard | 23/5/2010

Doubting among the Zafimaniry

Maurice Bloch | 16/5/2010

camphor - ammonia = anniseed x peppermint

Olivier Morin | 9/5/2010

Heaven before the space age

Brian Malley | 6/5/2010

Innocents fornicating and apes grieving

Dan Sperber | 4/5/2010

Is there a language instinct?

Nicolas Baumard | 1/5/2010

Endorsing evolution: A matter of authority?

Helen De Cruz | 27/4/2010

Are variations in economic games really caused by culture?

Nicolas Baumard | 23/4/2010

What explains the stability of animal culture?

Nicolas Claidière | 15/4/2010

On the Use of Natural Experiments in Anthropology

Nicolas Baumard | 5/4/2010

The social rationality of footballers

Hugo Mercier | 27/3/2010

Varieties of disbelief

Dan Sperber | 23/3/2010

Is the “problem of evil” universal?

Brian Malley | 18/3/2010

Cultural differences and linguistic justice

Nicolas Baumard | 15/3/2010

Pictures of the week: Globalized Prehistory in Arunachal Pradesh

Philippe Ramirez | 28/2/2010

Block and Kitcher review What Darwin Got Wrong by Fodor and Piatelli-Palmarini

Dan Sperber | 24/2/2010

Can you tell who will win the election in another society just by looking at the faces of the candidates?

Hugo Mercier | 22/2/2010

Religion science: if you pay the piper, do you call the tune?

Olivier Morin | 19/2/2010

Better live in Sweden than in the US: Why More Equal Societies Almost Always Do Better

Nicolas Baumard | 11/2/2010

There is no such thing as sexual intercourse

Pascal Boyer | 8/2/2010

Altruistic adoption in chimpanzees?

Nicolas Baumard | 3/2/2010

Experimental epidemiology: The work of Chip Heath

Hugo Mercier | 1/2/2010

Four recipes for religion

Harvey Whitehouse | 25/1/2010

Mad in America

Ophelia Deroy | 20/1/2010

Na'vi Cognition and Culture

Nicolas Baumard | 19/1/2010

Cognition under the high brow

Pascal Boyer | 14/1/2010

Cross potatoes

Brian Malley | 7/1/2010

Essentialist animals?

Helen De Cruz | 5/1/2010

Jingle Bell - Punjabi Tadka

Dan Sperber | 24/12/2009

Golden bell and Iron shirt

Brian Malley | 17/12/2009

Conversation Hackers

Olivier Morin | 12/12/2009

Three Questions for Simon Baron-Cohen

Emma Cohen | 8/12/2009

The scope of natural pedagogy theory (II): uniquely human?

Pierre Jacob | 6/12/2009

Can you tell the language of the mother from her baby's cry?

Nicolas Claidière | 2/12/2009

Death, where is thy sting ?

Pascal Boyer | 30/11/2009

The scope of natural pedagogy theory (I): babies

Pierre Jacob | 26/11/2009

Some like it hot

Ophelia Deroy | 25/11/2009

Language faculty? Semiotic system? Or what?

Dan Sperber | 22/11/2009

Astounding! Readers use their imagination when reading
Olivier's blog
Written by Olivier Morin   
Wednesday, 04 February 2009 00:00

La lectrice soumise, by Magritte

 

Everyday, in spite of the critics, neuroimaging keeps on producing vast increases in our understanding of culture. This week, for example, Boing Boing and Physorg enthusiastically comment on an fMRI study "forthcoming in Psychological Science" (though not yet online on the journal's website). The study discovered that "readers build vivid mental simulations of narrative situations".

For those unacquainted with the subtleties of Neuroscience, the authors explain: "Readers use perceptual and motor representations in the process of comprehending narrated activity, and these representations are dynamically updated at points where relevant aspects of the situation are changing. Readers understand a story by simulating the events in the story world and updating their simulation when features of that world change."

In other words, when you read the following sentence:

"It was a dark and stormy night"

You actually think of a night that is dark and stormy. You build, so to speak, a mental picture of it. And that image is in your head - in your brain. But there's more. When you read the rest of the sentence:

"It was a dark and stormy night - the rain fell in torrents"

You update your mental picture of that dark and stormy night, in order to include rain falling in torrents.

This, of course, is just a possible interpretation of the fMRI data. Let's not get too far ahead - this is science after all. Other studies might reveal that in fact you imagine rainbows and sunshine. Or maybe nothing at all. Actually, you might not understand english - you might even be unable to read. In both these cases you would not mentally picture a dark and stormy night. Or would you? We're only dealing with conjectures so far: we need more science of this kind. That study was only the beginning.

fMRI scanning costs around 500 dollars an hour. Marcel Proust's Sur la lecture is downloadable for free here.

Comments
Search RSS
Simon Barthelme 04-February-2009

My auditory lobe is simulating the sound of an open door being pushed.
No mention of mirror neurons in the press release? What's up with that?

I'd thought it was something universally known -  jose luis Guijarro 09-April-2009

Frankly, I don't find this astounding, for I have been functioning like that since my childhood --and had assumed, thereafter, that it was a common and universal experience. All the stories I have read in my life, from Red Riding Hood to Anna Karenina are remembered in my mind as if I had seen them happen.

This accounts for the fact that when I see a film with an argument from one of the novels I have read, I tend to think that the characters are not really as they should be. This happened lately with the film made after The Lord of the Rings whose characters were so clearly impressed in my mind that those in the film seemed fakes to me.

What's more, all my abstract concepts, say, PATRIOTISM, EDUCATION, CHURCH, MARRIAGE, etc. have an associated image in my mind. The only trouble is that they are not vivid images (I have trouble in seeing clearly some of their features), but they are like images in a dream. I know, for instance, that UNIVERSITY EDUCATION and SECONDARY EDUCATION are associated with two very different images in my mind, but if you ask me to describe one or the other, I think I could only stammer a few general characteristics.

Does that not happen to everybody else?

Only registered users can write comments!
Bookmark Google Yahoo MyWeb Del.icio.us Digg Facebook Myspace Reddit Ma.gnolia Technorati Stumble Upon
 

Creative Commons License
All the content and downloads are published under Creative Commons license